Wednesday, May 25, 2005

I am not getting it!

I was reading the process used by the South Korean scientists for stem cell research. They take a female egg and replace its genetic material with the DNA from a patient, and prompt it to grow into an embryo. From that embryo they develop stem cells, which are a genetic match to their donors. This technique of creating the exact clone of ones cells has the potential of treatment for body transplants, spinal injuries and genetic diseases like diabetes, so on. According to some scientists, the stem cell research may even find cures for diseases like Parkinson’s and Alzheimer’s. Opponents to stem cell research appear to have two major concerns. One is that in creating stem cells one is destroying the ‘potential of human life’. I do not understand this. Do they want ALL female eggs to achieve its potential of becoming human beings? (Are they sad when a woman has her period??) The other concern appears to be that an “embryo is a person”, and hence one is killing a person when they make stem cells from it. This also does not make sense to me. The eggs are not ‘fertilized’ with male sperm to create embryos for stem cell research; hence cannot ever develop into a human being. Am I missing something here?

1 Comments:

At 10:52 PM, Blogger PJ said...

I think I finally figured out what is going on. In USA, the stem cell research uses extra or discarded 'fertilized' embryos from the fertility clinics. South Korean scientists use embryos created without fertilization. It is time to let the USA scientists catch up, instead of criticizing their 'primitive' method of stem cell research!

(As for Bush holding the 'vitro baby', the fact that quite a few embryos are wasted (fails) before one catches on to be become a baby, is forgotten. If we can waste a few embryos to create a new life, why cannot we waste a few to save a life?)

 

Post a Comment

<< Home